Volume 19 No 19 May 2002
Editor's Notes & Reader's Views
Editor's Notes

Dear Readers,
The situation at Indo-Pak border has never been more tense or volatile as today. Unfortunately, despite being a nuclear nation and yearning to be a global super power, India instead of showing great constraints and responsibility, is bringing the region to the brink of great disaster and human tragedy. Pakistan remains committed to the principle stand to, not only fight against any kind of terrorism but also prevent its soil from being used for any terrorist group. To this end, Pak Authorities have already taken positive steps to curb this menace and offered unconditional negotiations to reduce the war hysteria. Ensuring that such an offer may not be construed as weakness, Pakistan has sent very strong signals to the Indian war lords and world community that, if attacked, Pakistan shall retaliate with complete might and resolution. It now rest on Indian leadership, whether to act in sanity and responsibility or be called by posterity, as biggest criminals against humanity. Unfortunately, so far, not a single signal has been received from Indian side, about defusing of situation. Their ‘record’ is struck on, “terrorists are infiltrating from Pakistan.” A diplomat friend in private remarked, if a million strong Indian army equipped with hi tech surveillance system and armed to teeth with sophisticated weapons, deployed in three defensive layers with deadly mines along LOC in Kashmir, fail to stop infiltration then it should be disbanded." We hope sincerely, that saner elements shall prevail and bring peace to the region.

We wish happy reading.


It's Our Fault
The targeting of doctors, Americans, Shias and Sunnis is the product of our apathy and our acceptance of the present state of affairs as 'normal'. Unfortunately, nobody's life is safe in Pakistan and before we become another statistics, let us do something about it.
All professional bodies can get together and make loud protests and the media can play its part by highlighting every murder as frontline national news rather than a small inside page story.
Let enough be enough and let's all play our part to stop this menace.

Dr. Shahab Mahdi, Shrewsbury, UK

Reader's Views

Federal taxes

In his recent interview on ARY digital TV, Mr Altaf Hussain of the MQM stated that 62 per cent of the federal revenues were contributed by Sindh. This is a gross distortion of facts.
It must be appreciated that all taxes are actually paid by individuals and not by companies. It is known to all that companies pass on the burden of indirect taxes to their customers by including the tax into the price of their products. If the products of a company are sold all over Pakistan, it is not correct to attribute the entire tax paid by the company to Sindh just because the head office of the company is located in Karachi.
To find out what percentage of tax has been paid by each province, we need to know the proportion of the products of the company sold therein. Likewise, in the case of direct taxes, such as corporate income tax, the burden of tax falls on the shareholders of the company, not all of whom reside in the province in which the head office of the company is located. From the above, it is obvious that the determination of the contribution of each province to federal taxes requires an elaborate exercise. One would, however, be greatly surprised if the contribution of each province to federal taxes turns out to be very different from its share of the national product.

Asaf Ali Shah Lahore

A lesson to learn from crows

This is reference an article about crows in Reflections. I've read about many campaigns to get rid of crows. But they are not all in all bad. An incident a few days ago just outside my house alerted my attention. The crows were creating such a storm, reminiscent of Alfred Hitchcock's movie that I had to go outside and see what the din was about. There was one crow lying dead on the road and what mayhem....
There is a lesson we can learn from these so called menace birds people wish to be rid of. Daily, people are being killed in Pakistan, particularly in Karachi, and no one bats an eyelid. Why can't we stand up like the crows for the death of one of our own; doctors, lawyers, philanthropists, educationists all being killed at the hand of terrorists and both the government and the people remain silent.
The culprits should be caught and punished. Then let us see if this is repeated. Why this apathy? Why this slackness?

S. Babar Karachi

Corporal punishment

It has been reported that in a well-known high school of Hyderabad, a boy was severely beaten by his teacher and had to be rushed to the hospital in critical condition. In this age, when we are so enthusiastic about following western models from fashion to political systems, and spare no opportunity to show our concern for human rights, how can we connive at such inhuman incidents. This is in not education but barbarism.
The concerned quarters ought to take stern action in this regard. Corporal punishment, in any form, must be completely banned in schools.

Tarik Omrani Hyderabad

Tourism promotion

The Pakistan Tourism Development Corporation is introducing a bus service to connect Islamabad with stations of tourist attraction like Naran, Chitral, Swat, Hunza, Skardu and Gilgit. Unfortunately, despite immense interest shown by tourists in these areas, successive governments made no worthwhile efforts to promote tourism in the Northern Areas. Sri Lanka is earning huge foreign exchange from tourism, but in Pakistan the number of tourists is on the decline. This is only because we have failed to develop the necessary infrastructure to make tourist spots accessible to tourists.
The tourism industry has suffered a lot in the wake of the Sept 11 incident that has led to a drastic decrease in the flow of tourists from the United States and other western countries. This calls for rebuilding the tourism market but the government alone cannot do the job. Tour operators, hotels and airlines would have to make joint efforts to promote tourism.
The law and order situation in the country, too, is not encouraging for tourism. Our missions abroad should try to create a better perception of Pakistan in the host countries to help increase the inflow of tourists.

Amjad Karim Rawalpindi

Recruitment of Mukhtiarkars

I would like to ask the secretary of the Sindh Public Service Commission if a syllabus has been prescribed for the written test for the post of Mukhtiarkar.
If yes, then why has this office not supplied a copy of it along with the application forms? If the answer is 'no', then how can we prepare for that test? I'll be thankful if the position is clarified.

Ashique A Lashari Khairpur



Reproduction of material from any Reflections Monthly Magazine without written permission is strictly prohibited......Copyright © 2001,03 Vreflect.com. All rights reserved.